A federal judge has drawn criticism following the sentencing of Nicholas Roske, who attempted to assassinate Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh in 2022. Roske, who now identifies as a transgender woman named Sophie, received an eight-year prison sentence from U.S. District Judge Deborah Boardman. The sentencing came just before the Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision, which overturned Roe v. Wade. The Department of Justice had sought a 30-year sentence, but the judge sided with the defense’s request for eight years, citing several mitigating factors.
Judge Boardman stated during sentencing that while Roske’s actions were “reprehensible,” his voluntary surrender and cooperation with law enforcement were taken into account. Roske had called 911 before carrying out the plan, leading to his arrest. His defense argued he was remorseful and dealing with significant mental health challenges, including suicidal ideation and gender identity struggles.
The sentence has sparked backlash from conservative commentators and social media users who believe the punishment was too lenient. Some critics also focused on Roske’s gender identity, questioning whether it influenced the sentence or prison placement. Others expressed frustration that the attempted attack on a Supreme Court Justice did not result in a more severe penalty, especially compared to other federal crimes.
The Justice Department has announced plans to appeal the sentence, arguing it does not reflect the seriousness of the crime. U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi called the attempted assassination an attack on the judicial system and labeled the punishment as insufficient.
Roske, in a letter to the court, expressed regret and said he abandoned his plan after realizing the reality of his actions. He described his struggles with mental health, identity, and a strict religious upbringing, saying he hoped to rebuild his life and contribute positively to society.
Judge Boardman, a former federal public defender, was appointed by President Biden and confirmed in 2021.
