For generations, many have been puzzled or even alarmed by the harsh wording on pillow and mattress tags: “UNDER PENALTY OF LAW THIS TAG NOT TO BE REMOVED EXCEPT BY THE CONSUMER.” But rest easy—if you’re the buyer, it’s perfectly legal to remove that tag. This longstanding warning is actually directed at retailers and manufacturers, not you. Originally introduced in the early 1900s, these law labels were meant to protect consumers from deceitful manufacturing practices when bedding could be filled with anything from old rags to unsanitary materials. The goal was to ensure transparency in what goes into our pillows, mattresses, and cushions.

Once you’ve bought the item, you’re legally in the clear to cut off that tag. The “penalty of law” clause no longer applies. Still, while removing it won’t get you in trouble, it’s worth considering why you might want to keep it. These tags often include important information such as warranty details, cleaning instructions, or filler material lists. If you plan to return the product, donate it, or pass it on, having the original label intact might be required by stores or charities. So before grabbing the scissors, take a moment to think about its future usefulness.

However, tags on baby products are another matter. Items like car seats, cribs, and infant mattresses often contain safety warnings, expiration dates, and compliance information. Removing these could invalidate warranties or hide essential safety standards. In those cases, it’s best to leave the tags in place entirely. With children’s products, safety always outweighs comfort or aesthetics.

So why the scary language? It’s a leftover from an era when manufacturers had to be kept in check with strict legal language. Over time, the tags became a tradition—even though the true enforcement now targets only sellers. For consumers, the warning is more historical artifact than legal threat, meant to ensure product honesty rather than scare you away from making your bedding more comfortable.

In the end, if the tag is keeping you up at night, feel free to remove it—just check if it holds any information you may need. Rest assured: the tag police aren’t coming. Sleep well.