Former Supreme Court Justice David Souter, appointed by President George H.W. Bush and known for his unexpected liberal rulings, passed away at the age of 85. Serving nearly two decades, Souter was a quiet, low-key figure who avoided the national spotlight and was dubbed the “stealth nominee” when he was chosen to replace Justice William Brennan.
Originally seen as a conservative pick, Souter surprised many by siding with the court’s liberal wing on key issues. Early in his tenure, he helped uphold the core principles of Roe v. Wade and consistently supported decisions on civil rights, affirmative action, and voting rights. His rulings disappointed many conservatives, leading to calls for more ideologically vetted judicial nominees.
Despite his liberal-leaning decisions, Souter demonstrated judicial restraint and intellectual rigor. His approach to the Constitution emphasized its enduring nature, insisting it was a living document meant to guide future generations. His rulings often reflected a measured and thoughtful balance rather than ideological fervor.
One notable case was his 1995 unanimous First Amendment decision allowing Boston’s St. Patrick’s Day parade organizers to exclude an LGBTQ group, showing his nuanced views on religious and free speech issues. Later, he argued that government must remain neutral on religious beliefs, citing the establishment clause to prevent divisiveness.
to the future.”
Souter resigned from the Court in 2009 at age 69, a rare move reflecting his desire for a quieter life away from Washington’s political pressures. His retirement paved the way for President Barack Obama to nominate Sonia Sotomayor, now a leading liberal voice on the Court.
Souter spent his retirement in New Hampshire, occasionally serving on lower courts. Known for shunning modern technology, he famously opposed cameras in the courtroom and preferred writing opinions by hand, embodying a thoughtful, old-school judicial philosophy.
